Who to follow Playbooks Checklist Method FAQ Compare

Copy Trading Allocation and Fill Audit

Check proportional sizing, skipped positions, cash movements and follower fills before comparing returns.

Primary-document review checked 8 October 2026. No funded account, individual-trader ledger or live replication test was supplied.

Define the Relationship

Record the platform, legal entity, broker, account type, currency, selected leader and copying mode. A manual signal subscription, an automated copier and an investment product are not interchangeable. Identify who chooses trades, who holds funds and who can change allocation. Save the agreement that applies to your jurisdiction rather than relying on another country's product page.

Do not start by selecting the highest displayed return. First decide which market exposures and potential losses you understand. A long leader history may describe an account that differs materially from yours. Instrument permissions, leverage, minimum order sizes and existing positions can prevent proportional replication even when the copying system is working as specified.

Record the Starting State

Take an authorised account snapshot immediately before the copy relationship begins. Include cash, open positions, pending orders and any manual holdings. Note whether the service copies existing positions, future activity or a permitted combination. Joining an existing trade today does not give you the leader's historical entry price.

Keep the amount assigned to the relationship separate from total account equity. If you later add or remove money, record both the time and the service's stated reallocation behaviour. Without cash-flow records, a change in account value can be mistaken for investment profit. A copy portfolio should not be judged using an unrelated account balance.

Build an Instruction-to-Fill Chain

For each selected event, link leader instruction, copier decision, follower order and follower fill. The follower status may be skipped, rejected, partially filled or still pending. Preserve those outcomes; counting only completed winners creates a selection bias. If the leader identifier is not available, describe the matching uncertainty.

Record the instrument as the broker identifies it, including currency and contract size. Similar ticker text does not prove identical exposure. If you compare price differences, normalise direction and units first. A raw numerical difference between two differently quoted symbols is not a meaningful slippage measure.

Explain Rounding and Minimums

A proportional allocation can be smaller than the account's minimum executable trade. The notional worksheet illustrates rounding down in a deliberately simplified USD setting. It does not reproduce any named broker's lot-size or margin rules. Use the actual contract specification when assessing a real order.

Treat unused allocation as a visible result, not an arithmetic error to hide. A small account may end up with a different mix of positions because the smallest intended orders are omitted. Repeatedly rounding only some instruments changes concentration. Compare exposure weights as well as headline returns, and distinguish intentional settings from execution failures.

Reconcile Costs and Exit Behaviour

Use your own statement for spread, commissions, financing and conversion costs. If a platform advertises no extra copying fee, that does not establish zero underlying trading costs. Keep each cost category and period visible. Do not subtract a leader's cost estimate from a follower's different account.

Read what pause, stop copying and keep positions mean for the particular service. A stopped relationship can leave positions requiring independent management if that is the selected option. Test understanding in a demo or with documentation before committing funds. This publication did not perform a funded replication test and does not predict your results.

Primary Sources

Copy Allocation Rounding Worksheet

Related research

Verify a Copy Trader's Record

Audit leader identity, cash flows, unresolved trades and follower fills before treating a selected copy-trading history as evidence.

Is Copy Trading Worth It?

Compare follower-side fees, executable minimums, monitoring responsibilities and cash-flow evidence without forecasting copy-trading returns.

Copy Trading Warning Signs

Investigate unclear identity, missing history, allocation mismatches and ambiguous stop controls without inventing fraud allegations or subscriber outcomes.

A reproducible comparison, not a completed audit

The retained allocation discussion is complemented by an authored row ledger. The publication does not claim that filling the ledger constitutes an independent broker audit. Intention, actual fill, product mapping and source coverage remain separate evidence tasks.

The packet has 1,930 intended units, of which 400 remain unresolved in the base. Its known subset contains both under-target and over-target rows. Those amounts are retained separately rather than hidden in a net. The calculator cannot detect semantic duplicates supplied under different IDs. A real reconciliation needs parent-source relationships and authoritative account observations. Broker reconciliation remains null in every export. A precise known-subset ratio is useful when it stays attached to those limitations instead of claiming identical full account paths.

Keep the record boundary

The authored journals are not empirical provider tests. A valid decimal result can still use an incomplete population or incompatible product definition. Keep the account card, mapping, period and source coverage with the interpretation. The tool cannot authenticate an observation, discover omitted events or choose a causal explanation for divergence. Original personal and provider claims remain unchanged. No new participant result or user-review aggregate is invented to make the comparison look stronger.

A comparison is not account management

Unknown fills remain null, observed zero stays a separate state, and below/above amounts retain their identities. A paired price-cost sum is not an investment return. The journals keep broker reconciliation, strategy validation and suitability null. They send no orders and change no native policy. A useful closeout states the supplied population and unresolved question rather than grant permission, recommend an allocation or promise that copying reproduces a leader's history.

Source and follower records